2026 Top 20 Pencil Eyeliner & Reviews
Pencil Eyeliner Products Top 20
-
1 No change in rank
CanmakeCreamy Touch Liner -
2 No change in rank
Too Cool For SchoolArtclass Smudging Under Liner -
3 No change in rank
Bobbi Brown24HR Waterproof Kajal Eyeliner -
4 Rank down
DiorDiorshow On Stage Crayon Eyeliner -
5 Rank down
&beUnder Eye Liner -
6 Rank down
Sister AnnDouble Effect Waterproof Eye Pencil -
7 Rank down
Etude HouseOh M'Eye Line -
8 Rank down
CLIOSharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Eye Liner -
9 Rank down
DiorDiorshow Stylo -
10 Rank down
CezanneDrawing Eyezone Concealer -
11 Rank down
Mac CosmeticsKajal Excess Long-Wear Smokey Eye Liner -
12 Rank down
TooqWaterproof Slim Eyeliner -
13 Rank down
CezanneBrepita Liner -
14 Rank down
ChanelStylo Yeux Waterproof Long-lasting Eyeliner -
15 Rank down
CezanneUnder Eye Liner -
16 Rank down
Kate TokyoPowdery Naginata Eyeliner -
17 Rank down
Kate TokyoReal Eyes Producer Double-Ended Eyeliner -
18 Rank down
Addiction TokyoThe Color Chic Eyeliner -
19 Rank down
OPERAEye Color Pencil -
20 Rank down
ViséeAvant Lip & Eye Color Pencil
Latest Pencil Eyeliner Reviews
-
Bobbi Brown24HR Waterproof Kajal Eyeliner1 weekI tried it on at the counter and bought it🎶 An eyeliner that glides on so smoothly and is easy to apply💖 The shade is 08 Cacao🤎 It has a creamy texture, and the tip is very soft, so I was able to apply it smoothly❣️ It feels lightweight and seems gentle on the eyes, which makes me happy💓 I could easily apply it to my lower lash line and waterline too, and the color showed up well💗 I'm also happy that it's waterproof and doesn't fade easily💓 My eyes tend to water and make my liner disappear easily, so I layer eyeshadow over the liner💗 Layering powder over the liner helps it last longer and also gives the eyeliner a slightly softer look🎶 This is a holiday limited-edition item and comes as a two-piece set with an eyeshadow palette💗 This set is very easy to use, and I recommend it❣️
-
-
-
+4
-
-
-
-
-
-
CanmakeCreamy Touch Liner3 monthsCanmake Creamy Touch Liner 03 Dark Brown This is seriously amazing!!!!! I bought it to use as eyeliner and it's super smooth and the color payoff is so vivid.....🫰🫰 It doesn't even come off easily, so it stays vivid all day... It literally doesn't come off even if you scrub it with water If you're looking for an eyeliner, you absolutely have to try this!! It's my holy grail 🫶.. + For extending the lower lash line, I recommend Cappuccino Pink! This shade was sold out in Korea for the longest time, and it's a muted rosy brown, so it looks natural and is sooo pretty
-
-
CanmakeCreamy Touch Liner1 year or more02❕ I bought it because everyone was into it, and now I get why everyone buys it! It's easy to use on the waterline! It's so thin, which makes it super easy to draw with, and I love it! But maybe because it's so thin, if you twist out too much and press hard while drawing, it snaps, so be careful⚠️ When I want a more natural makeup look, I can also use it instead of eyeliner at the outer corners!
-
-
CanmakeCreamy Touch Liner1 year or more11 Cloudy Gray This product completely changed my assumption that eyeliner had to be gel. I originally planned to use it on my waterline, but I was amazed at how easy it was to draw the outer corners. Gel has its own advantages, but sometimes oil on your face can make it hard to draw the outer corners. With a crayon type, I liked that I could apply it regardless of my skin's condition. I do think it comes off a little easily if I use eye drops a few times, but I'm extremely satisfied with how it feels to use. It's affordable, so I'd like to try a variety of colors.
-
-
DiorDiorshow On Stage Crayon Eyeliner1 year or moreI tried it at a makeup event and bought it💖 It glides on smoothly and is easy to draw with, with a soft, crayon-like feel🎶 It's waterproof and doesn't come off easily, and each one comes with a sharpener❤️ The sharpener is the same as the ones for eyebrow pencils and lip liners, so I keep ending up with a bunch of them💦 The other end of the pencil also has a smudging tip💖 The shade is 374 Green💚 I use it with blue and green eyeshadows🎶 When I layer powder eyeshadow over the liner, it seems to last even better and gives a softer look🍀 It also adheres well, so I think it's resistant to rubbing❣️
-
-
-
+4
-
-
-
-
-
-
ChanelStylo Yeux Waterproof Long-lasting Eyeliner1 year or moreShimmery liner💖 I tried it at the counter and bought it🎶 A twist-up liner🌟 It runs out faster than pencil types❣️ You can sharpen it with the other end, so it's easy to draw thin lines too💓 The colors are, 54 Rose Cuivré 46 Vert Émeraude 38 Bleu Métal Since you don't need to sharpen it, it's hard to tell how much is left, so it can suddenly run out💦 I feel like I want backups of my favorites🎶
-
-
-
+2
-
-
-
-
DiorDiorshow Stylo1 year or moreWaterproof eyeliner💖 The color is 771 MATTE PURPLE💜 It's a deep purple, and I think it gives a softer impression than black🎶 I use it a lot when I'm wearing pink or purple eyeshadow🌟 I wear contacts and my eyes water easily, and liquid liner tends to come off easily, so I often use pencil types❣️ There's a sharpener on the opposite end from the tip, so I sharpen it when I want to draw a thin line💡 I think it stays on better if you apply the liner first and then layer eyeshadow over it🎶 I also enjoy how the liner color changes slightly💖 I also like how it looks more natural🥰
-
-
-
+3
-
-
-
-
-
&beUnder Eye Liner1 year or moreI bought the Pink Pearl one after Yua Mikami introduced it on YouTube 1.2 years ago, and it was super cute! It's glittery, but since it's pink-brown, it has an elegant sparkle. Using a dark color for lower eyeliner can make your makeup look dated, but this color gives you a trendy look while still making your eyes pop. The tip is soft and easy to draw with too.
-
-
Mac CosmeticsKajal Excess Long-Wear Smokey Eye Liner1 monthNEW✨ New release launching on 2026/10/2 Kajal Excess Long-Wear Smokey Eye Liner 🩶 Smoked Quartz (pearl) The first shade I chose because I wanted to create a soft, smoky eye. A pencil type with just the right amount of softness. A waterproof liner that can be smudged right after applying and won't run. It comes in two finishes, matte and pearl, with 16 shades in total. I'm not sure if this is the right way to describe it, but personally, I think Smoked Quartz is a grayish taupe color. It sets quickly and won't budge even if you rub it hard once it's dry, but you can smudge it right after applying and use it like eyeshadow too. This shade in particular has a pearl finish, so the shimmery pearl effect when smudged is gorgeous 😍✨️ From trying it as an eyeliner, maybe because it's a subdued color, it doesn't feel overly metallic either. I also own a few shades of the Mac Cosmetics Colour Excess Gel Pencil, and that one is a pencil liner with a very creamy texture. Both glide on smoothly, but I feel like the new Kajal Excess is easier for me to work with.
-
-
CanmakeCreamy Touch Liner1 year or moreAbove all, it's so soft and glides on with barely any pressure, so I love that it doesn't tug much around the eyes✨ It gives rich, vivid color in a single stroke, and once it dries, the waterproof formula adheres closely to the skin, keeping the finish looking beautiful. However, the tip doesn't retract once you twist it up, so I'm careful not to twist out too much!
-
Too Cool For SchoolArtclass Smudging Under Liner6 months05 POSH is perfect for lining my waterline, so I keep repurchasing it and use it all the time! The tip will break if you twist up too much, so just be careful about that. The color payoff is great, it glides on smoothly and is easy to apply, and it’s an absolute makeup must-have!
-
-
CanmakeCreamy Touch Liner1 year or moreI own 10 shades. The ones I use most are: ・2 Medium Brown ・9 Darjeeling Pink ・16 Pretty Milk Tea These three shades. Even though it's affordable, what makes it so appealing is how easy and smooth it is to apply. Right after applying it, you can smudge it out or adjust the line, and once it dries, it becomes hard to rub off. It's the type that doesn't retract, and the tip is soft, so you have to be careful to twist up just a little at a time or it can easily break. Also, never knowing when it's going to run out keeps you on your toes☝️ Once you find a shade you like, it's so easy to use that you'll want to use it all the time, and I think it's a reasonably priced product☺️ In the third photo, I compared some similar shades from among the popular colors.
-
-
CanmakeCreamy Touch Liner1 year or moreIt doesn't smudge easily on the waterline, outer corners, or inner corner lines, so you can really define them! It also comes in lots of cute colors!
-
Sister AnnDouble Effect Waterproof Eye Pencil1 year or moreYou can use it in so many ways—as eyeliner, eyeshadow, for under-eye bags, glitter, and more—and the waterproof formula doesn't come off easily with water, sweat, or rubbing🫶🏻 I love it so much that I feel like this is the only eyeliner for me! I've repurchased it over and over😊
-
-
CezanneUnder Eye Liner1 monthI thought I'd use it instead of Canmake's Creamy Touch Liner, but it didn't glide on as smoothly as I'd hoped... It also feels a little too thick to use on the outer corner triangle or waterline. I use it to draw the shadow under my eyes.
-
Too Cool For SchoolArtclass Smudging Under Liner1 monthI've seriously been using the Too Cool For School Artclass Smudging Under Liner so much lately 🥹🤎 When defining the outer corners or adding shadow under my eyes, it doesn't go on dark like a regular eyeliner but adds a natural-looking shadow, which I really loved!! It glides on pretty smoothly too, so it doesn't tug as much when I apply it under my eyes, and if you smudge it out a little, the edges blend out naturally, making it easy to use even for beginners 🫶🏻 Especially when I apply a little to the outer corners, it makes my eyes look a bit longer, so I reach for it a lot when doing my makeup ✨ The color isn't overly dark either, so it doesn't look like too much under the eyes, and it was perfect for days when I wanted to add natural-looking definition to my eyes 💗 If you like makeup that elongates the outer corners or you're looking for a liner to add shadow under your eyes, I think you'll be pretty happy with this one 🥰
-
-
CanmakeCreamy Touch Liner1 year or moreThis eyeliner is so popular, it feels like pretty much everyone owns one🫶 Seriously, you won't regret buying this‼️ Great color payoff, glides on smoothly, doesn't smudge, doesn't budge—this eyeliner is just way too good💫 The tip is a little on the soft side, which I personally find easy to use🙆♀️ I'm a cool summer, and I love using 09 Darjeeling Pink 11 Cloudy Gray 15 Cappuccino Pink🎶 For 715 yen, this is way too amazing🥳
-
-
CezanneDrawing Eyezone Concealer3 monthsWhoa... this is insane🥹💭 Cezanne's new "under-eye bag concealer" is way better than I expected💭 Instant under-eye bags! There's no way this is only around 600 yen...!? I love that it's creamy and doesn't hurt to apply🤍 I'm so happy I can create natural-looking under-eye bags that blend into my skin instead of looking fake🐰🤍
-
-
-
+1
-
-
-
CezanneBrepita Liner3 months00 Black I didn't find it particularly difficult to apply, and the black is nicely pigmented, so it's easy to use for drawing a regular line. However, personally, I found it difficult to tightline with. I think it may also be because I'm not very good at eyeliner in general, but I'm also concerned that it's difficult to fix if you mess up, though I don't think it would be a problem for someone who's good at it. It's perfectly usable if you forget your eyeliner while you're out, but I feel like it's slightly lacking that deciding factor that makes me think, "This is why I'd choose it." If tightlining is important to you, I think opinions might be divided?
-
-
CanmakeCreamy Touch Liner6 months04 Garnet Burgundy I use it to line my lower lids and, depending on my makeup, for creating under-eye bags too. The tip is smooth and easy to draw with, and I love that it glides onto my lower lids without having to press too hard. It's easy to draw a thin shadow under my eyes and blend it out, so it works well when I want to subtly enhance my eyes. It isn't as harsh as black, and I think it's a color that gives a soft look even when used on the lower lids. Even though it's easy to draw with, it stays on relatively well over time. It's easy to use for lower-lid makeup, so this is an eyeliner I reach for a lot in my everyday routine.
-
Events for Pencil Eyeliner
-
Skincare · Haircare Log your routine
Win the Evening Ritual SetLog Skin & Haircare Routines, Win a Soothing Evening Ritual Discovery Set
All Viewduc members -
For our heavy reviewers Guerlain Serum Set
Post Reviews & Get ItGuerlain Serum Set Giveaway for Power Reviewers
Any Viewduc member -
1 REVIEWER WINS EVERY WEEK Share your review
Win a Dyson dryerWeekly Draw: Win a Dyson Dryer
All Viewduc members -
3 winners Christmas Gift
Win an LV Cosmetic PurseChristmas Giveaway: LV Cosmetic Purse
X followers · Viewduc members · Viewduc Crew