2026 Top 20 Pencil Eyeliner & Reviews

Latest Pencil Eyeliner Reviews

Review screening is active.

• 시우 Under 18 · Normal · Fair tone

  6 days ago
  
  Too Cool For School

  Artclass Smudging Under Liner

  I've seriously been using the Too Cool For School Artclass Smudging Under Liner so much lately 🥹🤎 When defining the outer corners or adding shadow under my eyes, it doesn't go on dark like a regular eyeliner but adds a natural-looking shadow, which I really loved!! It glides on pretty smoothly too, so it doesn't tug as much when I apply it under my eyes, and if you smudge it out a little, the edges blend out naturally, making it easy to use even for beginners 🫶🏻 Especially when I apply a little to the outer corners, it makes my eyes look a bit longer, so I reach for it a lot when doing my makeup ✨ The color isn't overly dark either, so it doesn't look like too much under the eyes, and it was perfect for days when I wanted to add natural-looking definition to my eyes 💗 If you like makeup that elongates the outer corners or you're looking for a liner to add shadow under your eyes, I think you'll be pretty happy with this one 🥰

  • 
  View original Helpful0
• mui Ages 25-34 · Dry · Fair tone

  1 weeks ago
  
  Canmake

  Creamy Touch Liner

  This eyeliner is so popular, it feels like pretty much everyone owns one🫶 Seriously, you won't regret buying this‼️ Great color payoff, glides on smoothly, doesn't smudge, doesn't budge—this eyeliner is just way too good💫 The tip is a little on the soft side, which I personally find easy to use🙆‍♀️ I'm a cool summer, and I love using 09 Darjeeling Pink 11 Cloudy Gray 15 Cappuccino Pink🎶 For 715 yen, this is way too amazing🥳

  • 
  • 
  View original Helpful0
• うぇるかま｜コスメが恋人💭Crew '26 Normal · Fair tone

  1 weeks ago
  
  Cezanne

  Drawing Eyezone Concealer

  Whoa... this is insane🥹💭 Cezanne's new "under-eye bag concealer" is way better than I expected💭 Instant under-eye bags! There's no way this is only around 600 yen...!? I love that it's creamy and doesn't hurt to apply🤍 I'm so happy I can create natural-looking under-eye bags that blend into my skin instead of looking fake🐰🤍

  • 
  • 
  • +1
  View original Helpful0
• 딸기미루쿠 Combination · Fair Light tone

  1 weeks ago
  
  Cezanne

  Brepita Liner

  00 Black I didn't find it particularly difficult to apply, and the black is nicely pigmented, so it's easy to use for drawing a regular line. However, personally, I found it difficult to tightline with. I think it may also be because I'm not very good at eyeliner in general, but I'm also concerned that it's difficult to fix if you mess up, though I don't think it would be a problem for someone who's good at it. It's perfectly usable if you forget your eyeliner while you're out, but I feel like it's slightly lacking that deciding factor that makes me think, "This is why I'd choose it." If tightlining is important to you, I think opinions might be divided?

  • 
  View original Helpful0
• 딸기미루쿠 Combination · Fair Light tone

  1 weeks ago
  
  Canmake

  Creamy Touch Liner

  04 Garnet Burgundy I use it to line my lower lids and, depending on my makeup, for creating under-eye bags too. The tip is smooth and easy to draw with, and I love that it glides onto my lower lids without having to press too hard. It's easy to draw a thin shadow under my eyes and blend it out, so it works well when I want to subtly enhance my eyes. It isn't as harsh as black, and I think it's a color that gives a soft look even when used on the lower lids. Even though it's easy to draw with, it stays on relatively well over time. It's easy to use for lower-lid makeup, so this is an eyeliner I reach for a lot in my everyday routine.

  • 
  View original Helpful0
• 平日loveちゃん Ages 18-24 · Dry · Light Medium tone

  2 weeks ago
  
  Dior

  Diorshow Stylo

  It's an eyeliner that's neither black nor brown. The color is purple. I got to try it at a Dior event and was so impressed that I bought it. I recommend it for people who want a more polished look but don't know where to start. You might think, purple...? But it actually blends right in. It's a little tricky to apply toward the inner corners of your eyes, but if you draw it on little by little instead of all at once, the color shows up. I'd recommend it to anyone who wants to switch up a makeup routine that's gotten stale.

  • 
  • 
  View original Helpful0
• ぽつ🐱 Ages 25-34 · Combination · Fair Light tone

  2 weeks ago
  
  Canmake

  Creamy Touch Liner

  Liquid eyeliner and pencil I use both in my everyday makeup, and I use this as a base for liquid liner on both the inner and outer corners of my eyes. It glides on so smoothly but doesn't smudge, it's hard to rub off, and I always repurchase it💗 I think it's also good for drawing an inner corner line when you don't want it to look too defined‼️ It's affordable and comes in lots of colors, so it works for both natural makeup and full glam!

  • 
  View original Helpful0
• rinaCrew '26 Ages 25-34 · Combination · Light Medium tone

  3 weeks ago
  
  Tooq

  Waterproof Slim Eyeliner

  It looks super cute when I use it on the outer corner triangle. It glides on so easily, I really like it color: Rosy Mute

  • 
  • 
  View original Helpful0
• Luna☪︎ Sensitive · Fair Light tone

  3 weeks ago
  
  Canmake

  Creamy Touch Liner

  I've heard it's consistently popular in both Korea and Japan 🐈‍⬛ It's a gel eyeliner that's very easy to apply Texture: Soft Creamy, almost melting How it feels: Glides on smoothly and easily Looks more natural compared to liquid liner 《What I liked》 ・Above all, the ease of application is outstanding✨ It's easy to fill in between the lashes and line the waterline ・Great value👍 ・If you let it dry properly, it's less likely to smudge or give you panda eyes 《Things to note》 ・It's pretty long-lasting, but I wouldn't say it's completely invincible all day long ・Liquid liner is easier for drawing bold, defined lines and delicate curves 【Overall】 Its biggest appeal is how easy it is to apply, almost like it combines the best of pencil and liquid liners, and it's versatile and easy to use. I sometimes see reviews saying the soft tip breaks easily, but I've been able to use it without breaking by twisting up only 1 mm instead of extending it too far🌙

  • 
  View original Helpful0
• 若作り。 Ages 35-44

  3 weeks ago
  
  Cezanne

  Drawing Eyezone Concealer

  It's understated, but I can't do without it. ⋆┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈⋆ Cezanne Drawing Eyezone Concealer 　 ⋆┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈⋆ This is my absolute favorite and a must-have that I always use whenever I do my eye makeup. It's not a flashy product, but it's incredibly easy to use, and I think it's one of those products that nothing else can replace. It glides on smoothly, so I don't have to worry much about friction even when using it around my eyes, and it's also excellent at staying put all day without breaking down thanks to its strong adhesion✨ It's convenient not only for the eye area, but also for covering small pimples, dark spots, and moles. The shade is natural too, and the brightness and color are just right for my warm undertone. I think under-eye puff makeup looks cute when younger people go all out with it, but when I, as someone in my late 30s, do the same thing, it still looks unnatural and stands out💦 But if I do nothing, I can't help noticing the empty space on my face that seems to get bigger every year. After brightening under my eyes with this concealer and then lightly applying eyeshadow over it, I feel like I can emphasize my under-eye puff a little without looking overdone. (At least, that's how it seems to me.)
 If this ever gets discontinued, I will seriously be in trouble😅 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - #DrugstoreMakeupMustBuy #Cezanne #CEZANNE #AffordableMakeup #BudgetMakeup #WarmSpring #WarmAutumn #Concealer #UnderEyePuffMakeup #EyeMakeup

  • 
  View original Helpful1
• なでしこ🌸アラフォーママのプチプラ時短美容 Ages 35-44 · Combination · Medium tone

  4 weeks ago
  
  Canmake

  Creamy Touch Liner

  I bought it just to try because it had such good reviews. Maybe because I press down hard, but I felt like the tip broke easily. I usually only use eyeliner on the outer corners of my eyes, so having the line get thicker because the tip broke is a real pain too. I recommend it to people who use a slightly lighter shade to draw their aegyo-sal or do makeup that lines the entire eye with eyeliner!

  • 
  • 
  • 
  View original Helpful0
• mipoCrew '26 Ages 25-34 · Combination · Fair Light tone

  1 months ago
  
  Canmake

  Creamy Touch Liner

  【02 Medium Brown】 I love how easy it is to draw both waterlines and eyeliner with this 🩷 I’ve repurchased it so many times I’ve lost count! 【09 Darjeeling Pink】 A warm-toned pink with a slight orange tint 🍊 I use it for my waterline and jirai lines when I do brown-toned or warm-toned makeup! 【12 Strawberry Storm】 A grayish pink that’s perfect for cool-toned makeup 🍓 I use it for pink makeup eyeliner, waterlines, the shadows under my aegyo-sal... It works for so many things, so it’s such a shame it’s limited edition 😭 【15 Cappuccino Pink】 An easy-to-use pinkish brown with less red and orange than 09, and less purple than 12 🎀 It might be the easiest color to use!

  • 
  • 
  • +2
  View original Helpful0
• しらたまCrew '26 Ages 18-24 · Oily · Fair Light tone

  1 months ago
  
  Canmake

  Creamy Touch Liner

  Honestly, it’s hard to use. Maybe I’m just not controlling the pressure well, but it breaks like crazy‼️ But the color is sooo good, so when I see swatches from people recommending it, I end up wanting it, and since it’s cheap, I buy it anyway. It’s really good as a mucous-line shade, so I end up using it after all. But when it breaks like crazy, I get to the point where I’m like, “I’m never using this again!” and go through periods where I don’t use it. But in the end, I want to use it again. Maybe it’d be good if you can control the pressure? But it’s cheap, so you won’t regret buying one!

  • 
  • 
  View original Helpful1
• 룹 Under 18 · Combination · Fair tone

  1 months ago
  
  Etude House

  Oh M'Eye Line

  Etude House has such great brow and eye products~~ It’s a brand I always use, but especially this eyeliner is such an amazing bargain, you know? Even Daiso sells them for 5,000 won these days, but what branded makeup company discounts its eyeliners into the 5,000-won range this often? It even feels great to use 🤍🤍 This is a product I always highly recommend to the people around me

  • 
  View original Helpful0
• 초고농축Crew '26 Ages 18-24 · Oily · Fair tone

  1 months ago
  
  CLIO

  Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Eye Liner

  It definitely makes drawing eyeliner easy, and it goes on smoothly! I recommend it for filling in the waterline, too. The brown color looks natural and pretty.

  View original Helpful0
• 초고농축Crew '26 Ages 18-24 · Oily · Fair tone

  1 months ago
  
  Too Cool For School

  Artclass Smudging Under Liner

  When I first bought it, I felt like it was a bit stiff, but after using it for a while, it goes on smoothly and the color payoff is great. I use it to extend the outer corners of my eyes and draw aegyo-sal!

  View original Helpful0